8 Comments
User's avatar
Scott Carter's avatar

Thank you for a sobering article. Having never served in the military, I believe during battle one didn’t care whether his partner was from Ontario, Alberta or Quebec. Premier St-Pierre Plamondon’s statements are a great disservice to Canadian veterans and particularly those who sacrificed for this country.

He might read “Dieppe: The Shame and the Glory” by Terence Robertson.

Robertson cites that the Nazis treated French and English Canadian prisoners differently by giving rations to French soldiers only. To paraphrase one French Canadian soldier stating to the Nazis, while his fellow soldiers shared their rations with their English Canadian counterparts “ We are one nation and that is why we fought so well today.”

Cindy Hardy's avatar

Thank you for providing these clarifications.

Harrie's avatar

Thank you for compiling this background. Speaking as a now 75-yo transplant from the rolling hills of the cantons de l’est to Montreal circa 1969 — and you know how things were back then — I was mildly shocked to see PSPP wearing the poppy at all. Back in the 60s & 70s, if you supported Quebec independence, you didn’t wear the poppy. Could we file PSPP’s statement as an attempt to have it both ways? I have a feeling there’s going to be a lot of that going around. I enjoy reading your meticulous work!

Patrick Déry's avatar

Thanks! :-)

I think most sovereigntists’ stance on wearing the poppy changed over time. That being said, it’s still a bit hypocritical coming from PSPP, especially considering what he’s consistently repeating about Canada’s “colonial regime”. Hence his rewriting of history to make Remembrance Day about Quebec.

Learning Father's avatar

As usual, great piece

Chuck Kaplan's avatar

Petit-Esprit PSPP